The Beauty of Propaganda

Great Wave Naval Battle

Naval Battle in the Sino-Japanese War 1894-1895: Reminiscent of Hokusai’s famous woodblock of the Great Wave (神奈川沖浪裏)

War is horrific, but for most of history, unless you were a direct participant or a victim, you would not be fully aware of this fact, as those in power were able to control the presentation of conflicts and, thus, censor the images and stories that were presented to the public about the war. Such monopolistic control remains firmly in place in many states but it has always been partial, as demonstrated by the popularity of the war poets of WWI and the Vietnam war veterans who become public protestors after their return. More recently however, the true horror of war has become even more accessible due to 1) the growing ubiquity of camera phones across the world and 2) online media distribution. Two recent illustrations of such trends are the tragic images of dead and injured children that spread across the world during the conflict in Gaza and the gruesome beheadings shown in ISIS’ terrorist propaganda. Such images are admittedly presented in heavily edited versions in traditional media but their full unedited horror is now easily accessible to anyone with internet access and the required motivation.

A photographic image of Japanese soldiers from the 1894 Sino-Japanese war

A photographic image of Japanese soldiers from the 1894 Sino-Japanese war

A new web exhibition of Japanese and Chinese propaganda prints depicting the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895, jointly created by the British Library and the Japan Center for Asian Historical Records (JACAR) in Tokyo, illustrates just how far the presentation of conflicts has been transformed over the past 100 years. The images in the online exhibition are stunning and reflect how the events of the war were depicted and recorded by people at the time (although mainly those commissioned by the relevant authorities). The presence of prints from both the Japanese and Chinese sides also enable us to see clearly just how interchangeable heroic and villainous motifs are and how readily they are applied. Although photographic technology existed at the time of the conflict and there were photographs produced (see one example above), it was prints that were the main news media of the time. The prints were primarily produced using traditional woodblock technology and this lends them something of a historical/classical atmosphere when viewed today. Yet despite their undeniable beauty it is always important to remember the real horror and suffering that lurks behind such stylised representations.

Below I’ve selected some of the images that I found most striking but I would recommend that people take the time to view the full collection and read through the exhibition site for themselves. It is also perhaps worth mentioning that the majority of the images are from the Japanese side so there is an unavoidable imbalance in the images below and the exhibition itself.

(Click the images for larger versions)

Japanese Blizzard

Japanese soldiers endure a blizzard

War Negotiations

Negotiations from the Japanese perspective

Japanese Naval Landing

Japanese naval landing, note the defeated Chinese soldier in the bottom right

Search Light Night Attack

Another strong contrast which paradoxically presents the Japanese forces bathed in darkness as the heroes

Naval Battle

A highly stylised Japanese portrayal of a naval battle

Chinese Negotiations in Taiwan

Chinese negotiations in Taiwan, featuring indigenous Taiwanese people, who fought with China in the conflict

Chinese Naval Battle

A Chinese portrayal of a naval battle

Japanese attack on Chinese defences

Japanese attack on Chinese defensive forces

Chinese Cattle Victory

Chinese victory, achieved using cattle

Rising Sun

Japanese officer at a camp in China watching the rising sun- a blatant nationalistic metaphor but still remarkable art

Stylised Assault

Another highly stylised image of a Japanese assault on Chinese forces

Big Gun Officer

Japanese military might and the supposed bravery of officers in a less than subtle image of a very big gun

China & Taiwan

Chinese & Taiwanese forces repelling the Japanese forces- note the indigenous Taiwanese warrior brandishing two swords in the top left

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s